All research articles, review articles, short communications, technical notes and methodological papers submitted to IJFSI undergo double-blind peer review.
Double-blind review
In double-blind review the reviewers are not told who the authors are, and the authors are not told who the reviewers are. Authors therefore submit an anonymised manuscript and a separate title page. The purpose is to focus the assessment on the work itself and to reduce bias related to the identity, institution or country of the authors.
Each manuscript is normally assessed by at least two independent reviewers who are qualified in the subject and have no conflict of interest with the authors. Editorials and other invited editorial material are reviewed by the editors.
Review workflow
- Manuscript submission. The author submits the manuscript and required files.
- Initial editorial screening. The editorial office checks that the submission is complete.
- Scope and formatting assessment. Manuscripts outside the scope of the journal or not prepared according to the Instructions for Authors may be returned or declined.
- Plagiarism and originality screening. The manuscript is screened for similarity to published work, and the report is assessed by an editor.
- Assignment to an appropriate editor. A handling editor with relevant expertise and no conflict of interest is assigned.
- Invitation of independent reviewers. The handling editor invites qualified reviewers.
- Double-blind review. Reviewers assess originality, scientific soundness, methodology, analysis, interpretation, presentation and ethics, and make a recommendation.
- Editorial decision. The editor decides on the basis of the reviewers’ reports.
- Author revision. The authors revise the manuscript and respond to each comment.
- Further review, if required. Revised manuscripts may be returned to the reviewers.
- Final acceptance or rejection. The Editor-in-Chief takes or confirms the final decision.
- Copyediting and production. Accepted manuscripts are edited and typeset, and authors check the proofs.
- Publication. The article is published open access.
Possible decisions
- Accept: the manuscript is suitable for publication, subject to copyediting.
- Minor Revision: limited changes are required; the editor normally verifies them without further review.
- Major Revision: substantial changes are required; the revised manuscript is usually reviewed again. A major revision does not guarantee acceptance.
- Reject: the manuscript is not suitable for publication in the journal.
Timelines
IJFSI does not promise a fixed review or publication time. The duration depends on the availability of qualified reviewers and the extent of revision. The journal will publish service standards once reliable data are available.
Confidentiality and integrity
Manuscripts and reviews are confidential. Reviewers and editors must declare conflicts of interest and must not use unpublished information. Manuscripts authored by editors or board members are handled by an independent editor and receive no preferential treatment.
Appeals
Authors who believe that a decision was based on a factual error or a flawed process may appeal under the Complaints and Appeals Policy.