Every manuscript submitted to IJFSI follows the same transparent process. The steps below show what happens between submission and publication.
Stages of the review process
- Submission. The author submits an anonymised manuscript, a separate title page, a cover letter and the declarations.
- Editorial screening. The editorial office checks completeness, scope, formatting and compliance with the ethical requirements.
- Originality screening. The manuscript is checked for similarity to published work, and the report is assessed by an editor.
- Assignment to an editor. The Editor-in-Chief assigns a handling editor with relevant expertise and no conflict of interest.
- Invitation of reviewers. The handling editor invites independent experts, normally at least two.
- Double-blind review. Reviewers evaluate the manuscript without knowing who the authors are, and submit a report and a recommendation.
- Editorial decision. The editor considers the reports and decides: accept, minor revision, major revision or reject.
- Revision. The authors revise the manuscript and reply to every comment.
- Further review. The revised manuscript may be sent back to the reviewers.
- Final decision. The Editor-in-Chief takes or confirms the final decision.
- Production. The accepted manuscript is copyedited and typeset, and the authors check the proofs.
- Publication. The article is published open access with its own permanent page and PDF.
Who does what
| Role | Responsibility |
|---|---|
| Editorial office | Screening, communication with authors and reviewers, production |
| Editor-in-Chief | Assignment of editors, final decisions, ethical oversight |
| Handling editor | Selection of reviewers, evaluation of reports, recommendation |
| Reviewers | Independent, confidential assessment and recommendation |
| Authors | Accurate and complete submission, revision, checking of proofs |
Fairness and confidentiality
The identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the process. Manuscripts and reports are confidential. Editors and reviewers with a conflict of interest do not take part in the assessment of a manuscript.
Time taken
The journal does not state a fixed review time. The duration depends on how quickly qualified reviewers can be found, the time they need and the extent of revision. Authors may ask the editorial office about the status of their manuscript at any time.