Skip to content
Diamond Open AccessNo APCDouble-Blind Peer Review ISSN: Registration in progressadmin@ijfsi.org
International Journal of Food Systems and Innovations

Reviewer Guidelines

Practical guidance for preparing a review report for IJFSI. Please read it together with the Information for Reviewers.

Before you accept

  • Check that the topic matches your expertise.
  • Check that you have no conflict of interest.
  • Check that you can return the report by the date requested, and tell the editor at once if you cannot.

Reading the manuscript

Read the manuscript once for an overall impression and a second time in detail. Ask what question the authors set out to answer, whether the methods can answer it, and whether the conclusions follow from the results.

What to assess in each section

  • Title and abstract: do they describe the work accurately and completely?
  • Introduction: are the background, the gap in knowledge and the objectives clear?
  • Materials and Methods: are the design, sampling, replication, controls, instruments and statistical methods appropriate and reproducible? Are ethical approvals stated?
  • Results: are the data complete and consistent, and are tables and figures necessary, clear and correctly labelled?
  • Discussion: are the results interpreted in the light of published work, without overstatement, and are limitations discussed?
  • Conclusion: is it supported by the evidence?
  • References: are they relevant, recent where appropriate, and accurate?
  • Supplementary materials: do they support the article?

Structure of the report

  1. Summary: two or three sentences on what the manuscript reports and your overall assessment.
  2. Major comments: numbered points on issues that affect the validity or interpretation of the work and must be addressed.
  3. Minor comments: numbered points on clarity, presentation, missing details and small errors.
  4. Confidential comments to the editor: conflicts of interest, ethical concerns and your recommendation.

Writing constructive comments

  • Be specific: refer to sections, lines, tables and figures.
  • Be objective and courteous; criticise the work, not the authors.
  • Explain why a change is needed and, where possible, suggest how to make it.
  • Distinguish between essential changes and optional suggestions.
  • Do not rewrite the manuscript or correct the language line by line; note if language editing is needed.
  • Do not include your name or anything that reveals your identity.

Recommendation

  • Accept: the manuscript can be published as it is, or after copyediting.
  • Minor Revision: small changes are needed that do not require further review.
  • Major Revision: substantial changes, additional analysis or new experiments are needed, and the revision should be reviewed again.
  • Reject: the work has serious flaws, lacks originality or is unsuitable for the journal.

Confidentiality and AI tools

Do not share the manuscript, and do not upload it or your report to public AI systems. You are personally responsible for the content of your review.

Reviewing a revised manuscript

Check whether each of your comments has been addressed and whether the changes have introduced new problems. Avoid raising new issues that could have been raised in the first round, unless they are serious.

  • Reviewer GuidelinesGuidance for reviewers as a Word document.
    Word (.docx)
Scroll to Top